As a gay doctor, I found the claim hard to swallow. How could such contempt for homosexuality not seep into clinical practice? Yet I am reconsidering my understanding after seeing today’s doctors face sanctions for weighing in on the Israel-Gaza conflict. Are belief and behavior always one and the same? Might we be punishing physicians too aggressively for their personal views? In 2019, a prominent doctor was publicly rebuked and removed as editor of a scientific journal after antigay comments he made came to light. Roberto Bolli, a cardiologist at the University of Louisville, had written a letter to his...