An aggressive dispute caught on camera—ostensibly between two far-right groups who had gathered to disrupt a Pride event in Oregon—has sparked a wave of theories about who was involved and why. Footage of the scuffle in Oregon City went viral after it was shared widely across social media over the weekend and, somewhat unusually, it was shared across the political spectrum of online commentators—because they all claimed it showed something different. While those on the left claimed the incident showed a fight between two homophobic groups who had gathered with the same aim of protesting against gay rights, others said...