In August 2022, at least nine student groups at the University of California, Berkeley Law School, adopted a bylaw excluding Zionist speakers, garnering national and global attention and ire, bringing to the fore both the rampant rise of antisemitism through the lens of "anti-Zionism," and the limits and boundaries of free speech, a bedrock principle of American law. As we sat and watched, the university wrapped itself up in a pretzel, trying to explain away, excuse, and minimize the conduct of its student groups. Incredulously, at the time the bylaw passed, the dean of UC Berkeley Law School, Erwin Chemerinsky,...