In May of 2021, over 200 scholars of Jewish and Israel studies, many teaching at prestigious universities, signed a letter responding to Israel’s recent operation in the Gaza Strip. The statement decried Israel’s foundations of “settler colonialism” and “Jewish supremacy,” placed the vast majority of blame on Israel for conflict in the region, and then cautioned against labeling economic and academic boycotts of Israel “antisemitic.” Jarrod Tanny, Associate Professor of Jewish History at the University of North Carolina, Wilmington, argues that the statement was the antithesis of all that the academy is meant to stand for. The letter replaced scholarship...